Re: The D&D Corner
Posted: Tue Jul 16, 2019 6:15 pm
This is nice... getting some compliments still!
DevilMcam;24018602 wrote:This is awesome.
Man_Over_Game;24019115 wrote:I apologize for not responding back, my weekend was pretty busy.
Your writing on the Moon Druid who doesn't want to be is pretty damn stellar. The hook at the end, where it's something forced by a god, got me pretty damn good. I envision this guy being completely spiteful, wearing a bunch of piercings and metal into combat like a medieval biker, with some of the alterations appearing during his Wild Shapes.
On the writing itself, I feel that the weakest parts are probably the conversation with the woman in the woods, as well as showing his disdain for his lineage early on. The conversation feels a bit clunky, although that can be fixed by simply saying that Barius feels odd and compelled to be forthcoming, or it could be cleaned up a bit so it's less clunky and more mysterious. The disdain in the early part of the story could be fixed with a little more explanation, maybe a little more angst, as it currently feels like "I don't like my father or being a Druid, because I don't like being told what to do", which is a bit empty.
Your storyboarding is on point. You definitely managed a damn good twist in a couple paragraphs, I just think that taking perspective of the emotional aspects from the audience's point of view might help clean up some more of the specific events. Amazing job, man.
^ SIDENOTE: I ended up writing two other variations of this person's request (which finally had one they were looking for!)DevilMcam;24020624 wrote:This is pretty awesome,
Actually Maybe à little to awesome for What I expected. to me Aasimar are like TIEFLING, they most lakely have never seen the planes.
For lvl 1 character I expected est less heroic behavior (for example we swap lucy with mayla in the first part : lucy get kidnapped, rescue party comme to save her, and vampire crumble to dust when they arrive, lucy is now à héro that did nothing)
Man the music though, totally on point
Daghoulish;24021093 wrote:This is really awesome. I've always been bad at making up backstories that aren't bullet points of things that had happened, so do you mind if I leave a character?
Ironheart;24021330 wrote: I think my faves so far are Jesse and Thaddeus, though I’m behind on page 3.
Here be feedback, and gushing. Mostly gushing!
Where do I begin? I really like the tension you’ve built between Gallindrann and Navani- admiration and rivalry are sides of the same coin, and you make Navani’s dilemma clear. She’s afraid to rock the boat with Gethel, and perhaps even took the relationship for granted, much like she took her powers for granted. This is the complexity that I was looking for in Navani’s background.
A couple of lines stand out as highlights are, to me, the most immersive.
There’s a couple of implications in this paragraph in particular that hints to Navani’s familiarity with sorcery (if I’m reading this literally enough?) which I enjoy lots and lots.
I think expounding on this scene, as the scene of her death, can be more immersive by her feeling the thrum of magic, before being left gasping for air as the orcs finish her off. I find the number and the fact she counted it in her memory speaks to the trauma of the event. I think 60 is a bit excessive, ten or so would do. That d6 hit dice isn’t doing her any favors.
A couple of things I think you could improve upon:
There’s a whole bunch of unnecessary dashes here! I think I was catching what was happening- there was a lot of things happening within these two sentences. If I would go over it, I’d put it like this:
“... as more than just a friend. In the event anything ever went wrong with the relationship, we reminded ourselves of how awkward it could be for our families. And so, we buried our feelings. But each time we looked at each other, or our hands brushed against each other, magic crackled and surged in our veins. I felt his way not because I was a sorcerer, but because this was something deeper.”
(Italics for phrases I subbed in to help the sentence flow a bit, or at least tried to.)
I broke up the two sentences into five here, but I still manage to vary the lengths and have it flow similarly. As Curly from City Slickers put it- Do one thing. I would add two things is okay for sentences. Most of the other instances this happens works out, because it’s often signaling an interruption when new information is presented, like Navani seeing her tongue when she’s already horrified by her skin.
Regardless, I love the direction you took with this backstory, and enjoyed the insights it gives into the Yuan-ti that just wants to cast disguise self forever. And that’s the big strength to your writing- as a background, it can be freely expanded upon. Things like other conversations and other elements can be freely added on.
Daghoulish;24021712 wrote:Wow, that's pretty fantastic. Way better than anything I could come up with. With the sorcerer sounding magic, yeah I can see that but I more see it that some orcs of the tribe are born into a pact(fiend in this case). Kind of like orc teiflings. With Truestirke carving out the old pact to make space for the pact, thus the unexpected stabbing. As for the unicorn, that was a surprise. I honestly forgot about the humble unicorn when I was looking at celestials, I was thinking a couatl but I really like this idea better. You wouldn't expect a orc to listen to a unicorn. I'm not sure what else to say beyond fantastic job, I love the picture you weave.
Jaryn;24021934 wrote:This is an absolutely fantastic thread - loving reading all the characters!
Bjarkmundur;24021987 wrote:THIS MAN IS UNSTOPPABLE!
I think it's the beard that gives him powers
AH0098;24022052 wrote:Your work is amazing. I wish I had your quick writing ability.
Jaryn;24023250 wrote:Thank you, that is brilliant! Pretty much spot on what I wanted. I particularly enjoyed the description of the parents and the scene where they found Alathiel.
I would say possibly even better if it had maybe one more paragraph. Would the character go out into the world immediately, or would they need to do a little training/discovery of other abilities too before they felt ready? Genuinely not sure at the moment if it needs that or if it's a better story with him just setting out... Also, for some reason I found the villagers chanting 'be the light' slightly jarring - but this is incredibly subjective and I can't put my finger on why, particularly as I loved the build up of him muttering about it to psych himself up.
Other things I very much enjoyed were the details like the name of the orc clan, and the closing of the guard's eyes before picking up his sword. Fantastic job, thank you again
MrSol;24023469 wrote:Bookmarked the thread for later reading. Absolutely love your writing style!
moonfly7;24024123 wrote:So, I always write my own backstories, and this next character is no exception. In fact, he is a main character in a book I'm currently writing, having first been made for DND, transferred to a book, and then back to DND. But quite frankly, your an AMAZING author, and I would be honored if you would take a crack at Asterius Velo, I need to see how you interpret this.
DrowPiratRobrts;24024973 wrote:This was great! He's a little more intelligent than I had in mind, but I still love it. Also, the description of that fight was perfect! It's exactly why I want to play him and how I'll fight.
MrSol;24026467 wrote:Holy Hell man! Gave me goosebumps! I cant imagine how much work you put into these things. I seriously appreciate it.
I especially like the relationship between his dwarven parents and him. The mother is just like what I would imagine a dwarven mom would be like. I feel like he will occasionally hear her voice in the back of his head: "You be careful now. Cant trust those Mere-folk. Breathing water! Unnatural."
Really like his Father too. Seems like the kind of person who would enjoy teaching his son what his father taught him, before him and his father before him and his father before him and so on.
Great Idea with the names btw, nice touch.
Also really liked the goblin and kobold raid and the necklace. They give good plothooks for later in the campaign that can be expanded on infinitely. My DM is going to love that.
Only thing I would add/expand upon (didn't mention this in the prompt so totally my fault):
I imagined Morgan having a made a bit of name for himself after he left home, as a smith of some skill. Not world famous by any means. Usually smiths in medium to large cities would recognize his makers mark or name. If they don't, they definitely know his fathers.
moonfly7;24026715 wrote:so, first things first: that was amazing! I love the work you did with Dorin, and the link you made between Asterius's eyes and magic? Perfect. Now, to asage ypur previous fears, this is DND Asterius, slightly different from book Asterius. Also, have you been sneaking into my house and reading my novel?????
Because in that, Asterius is raised in a great, magical library, where he researches magic.
Anyways, accusations of house breaking aside, this is amazing. I absolutly love this. I am totally using it for the DND backstory for him.
The only thing that I wpuld say is I have no Idea how he first gets into Artificery, my DM doesn't either. If you ever get free time and happen to come up with that, I'll be greatful. But feel like you have too!!!! This stuff is awesome enough on its own!
Bjarkmundur;24027574 wrote: I loved the suggestion-without-confirmation, using the Pillar of Light. I thought that was a cool way to show how the world isn't black and white, but instead a gray sludge of personal opinions. I attempted to go the more "pagan" route with the devil worship in order to keep it not-evil, but never thought of throwing a church into the mix! I imagined a poor and large immigrant family with its own tradition that was severely misunderstood be the city's native population. By interpreting "worship" as "church" you actually gave Barakas a much more compelling motivation to do what he does. I can see him joining our mercenary company and donating all the money to rebuilding the church. I can even use the Trollskull Alley Tavern rules for doing it, which I think is pretty amazing.
This was a very nice way to move the scenery from the splendor of Waterdeep to the setting where the story takes place. You move on to redeem the Southern Ward via it's landmarks. I feel like this would have better be done by focusing on the people, especially since the focus of the story is the community and the conflict within it.
As with part that came before this in the story, they are both great ways to show the reader Baraka's personality. It's amazing how well you seem to know MY character xD
This is the best part of this story. I love everything about this. The shock, the pacing, and how you managed to create a dramatic 'peaceful' action scene.
Having the Ceremony of Ascension representing the pact was a beautiful touch. You can make a promise to Mythia to become the best version of yourself, and go into the world without prejudice. Having accepted Mythia as your patron, she can then speak through you, like she does in this story.
dragonearth;24027699 wrote:Wow I did not expect this but I love it. I had no idea what to do with a warforged. This is defintly better than what I would have made, Many thanks.
I think because of how he was created in respect to Tarik that he is going to use his name. He also is level three at the start which could show the power used to make him. Also Van’shin I am coming for you
AH0098;24028068 wrote:
Wow that was amazing, I like the spear addition, I might make it an axe since that is a more Barbarian weapon instead of a hunting one, but wow. Thank you so much.
I can't help myself but request an other one, your writing is insanely good.
Jaryn;24029828 wrote:I am also just loving simply reading what you come up with.
CLAY MORE;24030801 wrote:It's quite good! Haven't thought of Caled's cromatic (and evil) heritage as a reason to enforce an eventual sorcerer multiclass. I'll talk with my DM to decide if any of his enstablished characters can fit the roles of Thorwal and Stern. Thank you!
^ This was probably one of the most flattering comments... they registered... just to ask me to write a character background for them! Amazing!Varise;24031955 wrote:Hey, long time lurker but finally convinced to register and post by this.
Bel-Torac;24032794 wrote:I love your backgrounds so far, keep up the good work.
Jaryn;24033105 wrote:Well please take my compliments for both fingers and mind - really enjoyed reading it - I could almost hear the music in the background!
^ This cracked me up, and reminded me of you Rath, for some reason!Bjarkmundur;24035239 wrote:tawmis-canon!
Tawmisverse!
Tawmsonian lore!
Yes!
Also - this cracked me up - in another thread where the poster was asking for the making of an Oathbreaker that wasn't evil (think someone saying, "I want to play a good aligned Sith!") since most Oathbreakers are Paladins of a Good Alignment who have turned away from their deity for some reason... I had posted a link to a recent Oathbreaker I wrote for someone in my thread, and this person posted in the Oathbreaker thread:moonfly7;24035267 wrote:This, this is good. Its awesome.
(Is it bad if I want to send you every character concept thats ever been have made just so I can see more of your work?)
Bjarkmundur;24035235 wrote:I just came by to check if Tawmis had already posted.
Carry on